The San Jose Short Sale Agent  shouted with glee today to celebrate the victorious outcome of a family which was able to successfully fight its battle against foreclosure today, as I was feeling proud and victorious.  The family which had endured the humiliation of being turned down for a loan modification by their bank, feeling they were without recourse, had come to me only two months ago to try a short sale as their last hope.   They felt they were at their wit’s end.   They came beaten and  humiliated.  It was bad enough they had to live through the indignity of unemployment which triggered their horror story, but their bank had refused to modify their loan or otherwise assist them.

But today they were victorious because the same bank which refused their loan modification request, had approved their Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives Program (HAFA) short sale and were willing to pay them $3,000 to help with their relocation costs and also had going to pay nearly $4,000 to pay off their HOA delinquencies and additional funds to pay off their delinquent property taxes.   Unlike two months ago, now the family felt they were getting vindicated.

That joyous feeling lasted a few hours as I read this  article today describing a different outcome for a person with a similar hardship which is headed towards a different outcome.   I obviously do not know the full details of Darlene’s situation besides what was described in the article below.   However, what I do know is that she was unemployed, suffers from cancer and fell behind in her payments which led to her foreclosure.

Typically three things have to be present to qualify for a short sale approval:  1) hardship (typically economic hardships) ,  2) monthly income short fall (meaning more goes out than coming in)  and 3) insolvency (meaning no assets).   In Darlene’s case, she certainly would have met the hardship (cancer plus unemployment);  the article mentions she is living on pension, social security and unemployment so I would assume she had a monthly short fall and probably did not have much assets set aside.   She certainly sounds like she would have been a good candidate for a short sale.

Additionally, if  this were her only home (primary residence), and as she was obviously delinquent on her mortgage payments and her unemployment and other income sources would probably have resulted in her paying more than 31% of her monthly income, there is a good chance she would have qualified for a HAFA short sale as well as Wells Fargo participates in that program.   If she qualified for a HAFA short sale, then she would have received $3,000 relocation assistance and up to $6,000 to pay off her second loan, if she had one.   Rather than being evicted with nothing to  her name or perhaps a small stipend – otherwise known as cash for keys – to get her out, Darlene could have saved herself the humiliation of being evicted from her home of 41 years and walked away knowing that she would have settled her debts with Wells Fargo and other lien holders.   She could have walked away selling her home with the bank’s blessing plus money in her pocket, rather than having the bank evict her and her neighbors of 41 years watching this happen.

The unfortunate aspect of this tragic story is that Darlene probably did not know that the HAFA option was available to her.   People in Darlene’s demographics do not often have the benefit of being able to research alternative options to foreclosures on the internet and take advantage of those solutions and the accompanying benefits like my clients did when they reached out to me two months ago.  Both of these people had similar hardships – unemployment (but Darlene’s case was worse because she also has cancer which was probably rapidly draining her bank account) – yet the outcomes will be dramatically different and each of these families will be celebrating the Holiday Season this year  in different states of minds.   It did not have to end this way for Darlene except that she was unaware and regretfully no one around her had given her the requisite  information.

If you are reading this blog entry, please share what you have read, so that people like Darlene do not have to suffer through foreclosures due to lack of knowledge regarding alternative options.   Please tell your grandparents, parents, neighbors or others who may be unable to surf the net for answers that there are alternative options to foreclosures; they don’t have to endure the humiliation of an eviction.  Please share with them that there is a Federal Government designed program to help out people facing foreclosures by offering them different alternatives.

 
San Jose Foreclosure Case is Both Tragic and Complicated

Unfortunately, foreclosures are no longer reserved for the sub prime borrowers.  Now it has spread to the mainstream.  All too often, it takes a few of bad months before the borrower falls so far behind, they are unable to catch up.

Besides job loss, catastrophic medical expenses is another common reason why homeowners are unable to make their mortgage payments.  This is a why we should have health care overhaul to make sure people are not forced into foreclosures or bankruptcies because of medical expenses.  The saga this family is living is being repeated by many other families here in Silicon Valley.